What are the key differences between Alteryx Designer vs Cloud?
Pros. and Cons.
Thanks,
Hammad
Solved! Go to Solution.
Any insights?
The first things I have understood :
-it's basically (formerly) Trifacta
-there are two experiences: the old one (trifacta legacy) and the new one (with a more "Alteryx" UX)
-there are similarities between the new Designer Cloud experience and Designer. However, it's clearly not the same... (such as management for in database, etc)
-you can't move your current assets from designer or gallery to cloud but Alteryx is working on it.
Everything else like pro and cons are classic such as scalabily, administration, etc/
I just hope all these products will converge. One UX, one training, several deployment types.
Thanks for the insights. Really helpful!
Good
Hi,
I came up with few comparisons based on my understanding, but as I am new in Alteryx world I would also like seek guidance from the pro-community to leave feedback around these comparisons. I would appreciate if someone who has actually worked with both on-prem and cloud to verify these comparisons and check if there is any modifications required or any pointers that could be added further, it would be really helpful.
Here’s a more detailed comparison table of Alteryx On-Premises and Alteryx Cloud, with elaborated descriptions for each aspect:
Feature/Aspect | Alteryx On-Premises | Alteryx Cloud |
Deployment | Requires installation on local servers or machines, involving significant setup time. | Cloud-based, accessible via web browsers, enabling quick deployment without local installations. |
Infrastructure Management | Managed by the organization’s IT team; requires resources for hardware and software maintenance. | Managed by Alteryx, reducing the IT burden and allowing teams to focus on analytics rather than infrastructure. |
Scalability | Scaling involves purchasing additional hardware or software licenses, which can be costly and time-consuming. | Highly scalable; organizations can quickly adjust resources based on demand without physical changes. |
Accessibility | Limited to internal networks; remote access may require VPNs, complicating access for remote teams. | Accessible from anywhere with internet connectivity, facilitating remote work and collaboration. |
Collaboration | Collaboration features may be limited, requiring additional tools for effective teamwork. | Built-in collaboration tools enable real-time sharing of projects and data, enhancing teamwork across locations. |
Cost Structure | Involves upfront licensing fees and ongoing maintenance costs, which can be substantial over time. | Subscription-based pricing allows for predictable monthly or annual costs without large initial investments. |
Updates | Updates must be managed manually by IT, risking outdated software if not regularly maintained. | Automatic updates managed by Alteryx ensure users have access to the latest features and security improvements. |
Data Security | Complete control over data security and compliance, crucial for sensitive industries. | Strong security measures implemented by Alteryx, but organizations must trust the vendor’s data protection capabilities. |
Integration | Integrates well with existing local databases and tools, but may require setup for cloud integrations. | Easy integration with other cloud services and APIs, streamlining data workflows and enhancing capabilities. |
User Interface | Desktop interface may require more training, particularly for new users unfamiliar with the software. | User-friendly web interface designed for ease of use, reducing the learning curve for new users. |
Performance | Dependent on local hardware capabilities, which can vary significantly between organizations. | Generally high performance leveraging robust cloud infrastructure, effectively handling large datasets and complex processes. |
Data Governance | Full control over data governance policies, ensuring compliance with internal standards. | Compliance relies on Alteryx’s security measures; organizations must ensure alignment with their governance requirements. |
Backup & Recovery | Organizations manage their own backup and disaster recovery strategies, which can be complex. | Alteryx manages backups and disaster recovery, providing assurance that data is regularly saved and can be restored. |
Summary:
Alteryx On-Premises is ideal for organizations requiring stringent control over their data and infrastructure, typically in regulated industries.
Alteryx Cloud is suited for teams looking for flexibility, ease of access, and reduced IT overhead, making it advantageous for collaborative and remote work environments.
@AA_alteryx I beg to differ on a few points :
1/Integration : on cloud, you can't access your local database, which is a huuuuuuuuge limitations.
2/user interface : I don't see how the Cloud UI is really easier than the on-premise one O_o. And at some point, the AACP is even harder to understand, since there are more kind of assets (like the notion of Datasets)
3/Performance : if you leverage in-database, you can have great performances with on-premise.
4/it lacks the biggest point of all : On-premise offers more than 300 tools, something like 10x more than Cloud.
Thanks for enlightening me with those points. Really appreciate.