Reconcile 2 sheets to produce one final output

[PaulDuffySmyth]

I am trying to produce a workflow that will reconcile to different files with the same columns and produce an output file with the results.  I am getting the output across the file and not down the file.  Sample of whats required is attached and sample workflow below.  Any assistance appreciated.

[KGT]

Without seeing the config of the tools, my guess is that you need a recordID on each file. Then select that as a key field and join field as well. You can knock it off afterwards if you like.